Go to content

2026_19_3_7 - XLinguae

Skip menu
Skip menu

2026_19_3_7

Open access Issues > Issue n_3_2026 > Issue n_3_2026
Confucianist Philosophy and Dialectical Marxism in Vietnam

Thu Truong Doan – Hoa Thi Kim Do

DOI: 10.18355/XL.2026.19.03.07

Abstract
This article undertakes a systematic philosophical comparison of Confucian philosophy and dialectical materialism as they interact in Vietnamese intellectual and political life. Against the prevailing “harmony narrative” in Vietnamese scholarship and the “replacement thesis” advanced by Nguyen Khac Vien (1974), we propose a model of layered coexistence: the two traditions occupy different strata of Vietnamese thought, converging on anti-individualism, this-worldly humanism, moral-political unity, transformative education, and the primacy of praxis, while diverging on ontology, historical methodology, social hierarchy, and the status of transcendence. Drawing on the concept of cultural additivity (Vuong et al., 2018) and a hauntological reading of Confucianism’s persistence (Linh, 2023), the analysis demonstrates that the Confucian-Marxist relationship in Vietnam is characterised neither by synthesis nor by conflict but by the simultaneous operation of genuine affinities and unresolved contradictions. The Vietnamese case challenges the Western assumption that ideological consistency is a prerequisite for intellectual seriousness, revealing a cultural logic that privileges practical coherence over theoretical purity.

Key words: Confucianism, dialectical materialism, Vietnam, cultural additivity, layered coexistence

Pages: 93-108

Full Text
Back to content